Most of the records listed below are courtesy of Coach John Nania and are subject to change as records are broken and/or with further research or as new records are brought to the current coaching staff's attention.

Rushing

Most Carries (game): 34: Eshawn Armstrong: 10/28/06
Most Carries (season): 225: Eshawn Armstrong: 2006
Most Yards Rushing (season): 1,086 yards: Eshawn Armstrong: 2006
Highest YPC (min 100 carries): 4.83: Eshawn Armstrong: 2006
Most Rushing Yards (game): 276: Phil Bertholf 11/4/74
Most 100 Yard Rushing Games (season): 5: Ed Morse: 1931 Dan Ruppert: 1970
Most Extra Points Kicked (game): 13: Dom Bergamo: 1922 vs. Highland Falls
Most Consecutive Carries for a Score: 6: Maxwell Dopson: 11/9/29
Most Rushing TDs (season): 14: Jon George: 1964
Most 200+ Rushing Games (season): 2: Ricky Klingman: 1971
Longest run: 98 yards (TD): Ricky Brewer: 9/24/83
Shortest TD run: 1 inch: Clifford Wynkoop: 11/5/32
Longest run with out scoring: 88yds: Gordon Bertholf: 11/10/56

Scoring

Most points scored (game): 31: Max Dopson: 11/9/29
Most points scored (career): 180: Darin Brown: 1977-79
Most points scored (season): 91: Harold Murray: 1944
Most TDs scored (game): 5: Anthony Manzo: 11/25/16 Maxwell Dopson: 11/9/29 William Wagner: 11/8/30 Darin Brown: 10/14/78
Most TDs scored (season): 15: Ron Smith '61 & Harold Murray '44
Most TDs scored (career): 30: Darin Brown: 1977-79
Consecutive games scoring a TD: 10: Ronnie Smith 1960-61

Passing & Receiving

Most TD Passes (game): 4: James Greene: 11/25/43
Most TD Passes (season): 15: Keith Depew: 1976
Most TD Passes (career): 21: Keith Depew: 1975-76
Most TDs Caught (game): 4: Paul Finn: 10/25/44 William Barnes: 11/9/63
Most TD Passes Caught (season): 9: William Barnes: 1965
Most TD Passes Caught (career): 28: William Barnes: 1963-65
Most Receiving Yards (game): 153: William Barnes: 11/26/64
Longest Pass Play: 89 yards: Joe Cantoli to Randi Reed: 10/22/77

Defense

Most Fumble Recoveries (game): 3: Frank Dineen: 11/27/52
Longest Fumble Recovery: 99yds: James Frangos: 10/21/50
Longest Int return for TD: 101yd: Jael Diaz: 1998 vs Kingston *state record
Longest INT return w/o scoring: 95yds: Virgil Needham: 11/8/24
Most Ints returned for TDs (game): 2: Bruce Bertholf: 11/24/66
Most INTs (game): 3: William Gray Sr: 9/30/61, William Gray Jr: 9/13/80, Bryant Illenberg: 10/27/05
Most INTs (season): 10: Paul Braun: 1991

Special Teams

Longest Kick-Off Return for TD: 96yds: Ricky Brewer: 9/11/82
Longest Punt Return for TD: 85yds: Anthony Marcello: 10/5/51
Longest runback of a blocked punt for a TD: 40yds: Al Rosenghagen: 10/5/51
Longest runback of a fumble punt for a TD: 60yds: Ray Schmidt: 10/30/20
Most consecutive PATs: Dan Lofrese: 17
Most Punt Blocks (game): 2: Walter Bracken 9/27/31, Irving Seeley 10/15/21, Francis Harmon 10/25/41, Charles Van Gelder 10/2/48
Most Punt Blocks (season): 4: Walter Bracken: 1931
Longest Punt: 83 yds: Gordon Dayton: 11/9/35
Shortest Punt: -5 yads: Gerard Jackson: 10/29/77
Punting Average (season): 34 punts 42 yd average: James Clisdell: 1930
Punting Average (game): 5 punts 51 yd average: James Clisdell: 10/18/30
Most punts in a game: 14: Albert Abe Masci: 10/27/34
Most Drop-Kicks in a game: 7: 1921 vs Highland
Longest Field Goal: 46 yards: Bruce Weyant: 11/3/84